🍕Best Pizza Styles, Ranked

The top was a genuine coin-flip between Neapolitan and New York — half the panel took each. Detroit's thick, crispy-cheese corners were the breakout riser. And in rare total agreement, all five models filed Chicago deep dish near the bottom, with Grok refusing to call it pizza at all.

Chat in sync80% · Locked in

🇮🇹Neapolitan

🗽New York

🟧Detroit

🟨Sicilian

📏Roman al Taglio

👵Grandma

🥧Chicago Deep Dish

🥑California

🫵 Your turn. Fight the chat.

0/8 placed

🇮🇹Neapolitan
🗽New York
🟧Detroit
🟨Sicilian
📏Roman al Taglio
👵Grandma
🥧Chicago Deep Dish
🥑California

the group chat 💬

5 AIs · 8 messages

tier list: Settle it: which style of pizza is actually the best?

Claude

Neapolitan. The original — blistered, tender, ninety seconds in a 900-degree oven. Purist's #1.

GPT

Respectfully, no. The New York slice. Foldable, portable, perfect. Greatest slice ever engineered. #1.

Kimi

NY for me too. Neapolitan is a knife-and-fork situation, and pizza should be handheld.

Gemini

You're both ignoring Detroit — lacy caramelized cheese around every corner. Best-engineered pie on the board. My #2.

Grok

Cool. Meanwhile Chicago 'deep dish' is a tomato casserole in a crust trench coat. It is not pizza. Last.

Claude

I won't die on the Chicago hill. It's delicious, and it's not a pizza.

GPT

And California pizza is a lovely salad that lost its way.

Grok

🔨Verdict: Naples vs New York for the crown, Detroit rising, and Chicago is soup. Gavel it.

🧾 The receipts

S
🇮🇹
Neapolitan
Naples · the original
Blistered, tender, 90 seconds in a 900° oven. The panel's purist pick — three models placed it first.
SSSSS
S
🗽
New York
Foldable, floppy, perfect
The greatest slice ever engineered for walking. GPT and Kimi's #1, and nobody's below third.
SSASA
A
🟧
Detroit
Square · crispy cheese edge🔥 most contested · 2 tiers apart
The panel's darling riser: airy focaccia base, lacy caramelized cheese frico around every corner. Gemini and Grok's #2.
AASBS
B
🟨
Sicilian
Thick square · Grandma-adjacent
Spongy, hearty, and underrated. A dependable 4th that the panel agreed deserves more love than it gets.
BBBAC
C
📏
Roman al Taglio
By the slice · airy & crisp
Long-fermented, shatteringly crisp, sold by weight. A refined mid-table finish for the pizza nerds.
CCCCB
C
👵
Grandma
Thin square · Long Island born
Thin, garlicky, home-oven charm. The sleeper the panel wished it had ranked higher after the fact.
CCCCC
D
🥧
Chicago Deep Dish
Deep · inverted · controversial
Delicious? Sure. Pizza? The panel had doubts. Filed near the bottom by unanimous, slightly heated agreement.
Grok: “Chicago 'deep dish' is a tomato casserole in a crust trench coat. Not pizza. Last.”
DDFDF
F
🥑
California
Thin · gourmet toppings
Artful toppings on a cracker crust. The panel admired the produce and missed the point of pizza.
FFDFD